Bauer’s attorney Anne Chapman told police that Bauer did pay Esemonu approximately $10,000 for “medical expenses, prenatal vitamins, and car services related to the pregnancy.” ...

Hill said it was an arrangement agreed to by both sides, although Bauer's lawyer had one condition. "The lawyer said, 'We have to make it look like Trevor didn’t pay her,'" Hill said.

The Columbus woman said she felt compelled to share her story after Bauer denied similar allegations made by two other women -- one of whom was also based in Ohio and, according to a Washington ...